What the Dog Saw -- Malcolm Gladwell -- Can't Reccomend

I've read a fair bit of Malcolm Gladwell and I'm having a hard time de-homogenizing "what the Dog saw" from Blink, and some of his other stuff. In general, my conclusions from this book are very similar to Blink. So let me just expound a little bit on that.

Gladwell does a superb job making dry, academic work, very readable. He weaves together interesting anecdotes and empirical evidence into a very readable piece. Unfortunately, his approach is not rigorous and his conclusions are therefore dubitable if not entirely worthless.

His ignorance is most prominent when he starts talking about the disciplines that I have studied the most (Business and Economics). A sociology professor I know thinks the same thing when he talks about sociology. I can only conclude that Gladwell is suffering from skimming the shallows without delving the depths. ("Death of expertise" and "the shallows")
Still, there are some use cases for reading his work.

It's a good starting point if you're interested in the subject, just don't let this be an ending point. It's also a good place to get a birds-eye view of some of the most interesting academic work and some of the most prominent anomalies in literature. The material he cites has been a launching place for several of my own academic investigations.

I can't recommend the book, there is too much ignorance and error, but it could be a worthwhile endeavor to read a chapter a night in conjunction with a real investigation, just to expand your creativity.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The righteous mind — Jonathan Haidt — Recommend with salt

Image
  The book in a nutshell is captured by the subheading "why good people are divided by politics and religion". The book can be roughly divided into thirds. The first half of the book is about the origins of morality. Where did it come from? Haidt touches on some philosophical works and debates and ultimately concludes that morality provides evolutionary advantages, and it supersedes reason. He uses an elephant and a rider analogy, morality, roughly equated to emotion, is the elephant. He also uses a president and press secretary metaphor, which I found helpful, reason's primary function is to rationalize the conclusions of the subconscious. I'm not sure this story fully explains morality. I think it could explain some of it, and it provides some satisfying guidance but tas far as I can tell it does not obviate the need for extra-human deliberate construction of morality. Second, he outlines what morality is and isn't. He rejects utilitarianism and deontology as to
Read more

The Sum of All Fears-- Tom Clancy

Image
The Sum of all fears  It’s classic Clancy. This one is particularly interesting in terms of the breadth of the problem and players. It’s very human and the technical details are as compelling as always. It also highlights the potential danger of MAD (mutually assured destruction) policy in a very penetrating way.  Check out my general Clancy post for a broader take on this series. Verdict Recommend
Read more

Foundation -- Isaac Asimov -- Lukewarm

Image
I read this because people I admire talked about it (Elon musk, Orson Scott Card, Ben Shapiro). It's classic science fiction in an ancient context. It was published in the 50s, 15 years before the earliest start trek, 25 years before star wars, and 35 years before Enders game, all of which are ancient history. In many ways, it belongs to the era of   Edgar Rice Burroughs'  Prince of Mars or even H.G. Well's War of the Worlds more than it does modern science fiction. That being said, there are some truly brilliant ideas explored in the text. First, the book doesn't follow a protagonist, which means no character development and no human story. Instead, Asimov overtly follows humanities' story, jumping from viewpoint to viewpoint and century to century in galactic civilization. In some ways, it reads more like a collection of short stories in Sanderson's Cosmere or perhaps even something from the MCU, but the novel still manages to drive a narrative crafted aro
Read more